PROPOSING DIYAT AS AN ALTERNATIVE TO DEATH PENALTY FOR THE CRIME OF MURDER IN MALAYSIA
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.22452/syariah.vol32no3.6Keywords:
diyat, qisas, death penalty, alternative punishment, Islamic criminal lawAbstract
Pressure has increased on retentionist countries, including Malaysia, to consider finding an alternative penalty to the death penalty for murder. In mid-2023, the government decided to abolish the mandatory death penalty and proposed alternative sentences for the crime of murder. Concurrently, the concept of diyat or Islamic monetary compensation has also been raised by many quarters for consideration. This article examines the concept of forgiveness and diyat and addresses the potential impact of incorporating them into Malaysian criminal law. Employing a normative empirical method, the study utilized literature from predominantly secondary sources. Normative analysis was conducted to describe the findings. It is found that diyat has the potential to replace the death penalty for intentional killing, provided that amendments to the law are made. Most importantly, the victim's heirs must grant forgiveness. This is because the victim’s family holds the right to decide whether to accept diyat, demand retribution or pardon the offender entirely. The core changes required include amendments to the Penal Code and Criminal Procedure Code. This article contributes to the existing literature on the harmonization of Islamic principles and law, and explores the potential applicability of Islamic law within the Malaysian legal system.
Downloads
References
Alaoudh, Abdullah Sulaiman, ‘Saudi judiciary: from the unpredictable unwritten to codified authoritarianism’, Arab Law Quarterly 36:4-5(2022): 536-540
Amnesty International, Fatally Flawed: Why Malaysia Must Abolish The Death Penalty.(2019), (https://amnesty.org/en/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/ACT5010782019ENGLISH.pdf) (retrieved 11/1/2024)
Amnesty International,Amnesty International Global Report: Death Sentences and Executions 2020. (2021), Retrieved from https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/act50/3760/2021/en/ (12/1/2024)
Anti-Death Penalty Asia Network. https://adpan.org (retrieved 11/1/2024)
Awang, Abdul Rahman, ‘Diyah (blood money) as substitution to capital punishment: An Attempt Towards Harmonisation Between Shariah and Malaysian Penal Code’, Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 6/11(2012): 106-112
Awdah, Abdul Qadir, al-Tashri' al-Jina'i al-Islami Muqaranan bi al-Qanun al-Wad'i .(Cairo: Maktabah Dar al-Turath,2003).
Awdah, Abdul Qadir, Criminal Law of Islam . Karachi: International Islamic Publishers,1987).
Aziz, Amir Abdul, al-Fiqh al-Jina'i fi al-Islam. (Cairo: Darussalam,1997).
Aziz, Shamrahayu, ‘The Continuing Debate on the Death Penalty: An Exposition of International Instrument, Malaysian and the Sharī‘ah Perspectives’, IIUM Law Journal, 23(2015): 61.
Bakhos,Carol and Cook, Michael. (eds.), Islam and Its Past: Jahiliyya, Late Antiquity and the Quran, (Oxford: Oxford University Press,2017).
Barnwell, P.S., ’Emperors, jurists and kings: law and custom in the late roman and early medieval west’, Oxford Journals: The Past & Present Society .168 (2000):6-29.
Bayhaqi, Muhammad al-, Al-Sunan al-Sughra. (Beirut: Dar al-Ma`rifah,1999).
Browne, M., S. Kandelia, S., Reddy, R., and Hodgkinson, P., ‘Capital Punishment and Mental Health Issues: Global Examples”, St Louis University Public Law Review, 25/2(2006):383-407
Burton, William C., Legal Thesaurus, (New York: Macmillan,1990).
Cao,Yulong, Hongbo Yu, Yanhong Wu, Zhou Xiaolin, `Can money heal all wounds? social exchange norm modulates the reference for monetary versus social compensation’. Front.Psychol . 6(2015):1411.
Cropper, M.,N. Simon, A. Alberini, Arora S., Valuing Mortality Reductions in India: A Study of Compensating Wage Differentials (2022). Retrieved from http://www.documents1.worldbank.org) 11/12/2023
Cropper, M.,N. Simon, A. Alberini, Arora S., Valuing Mortality Reductions in India: A Study of Compensating Wage Differentials.(2022) Retrieved from http://www.documents1.worldbank.org) 11/12/2023
Darimi al-, Sunan al-Darimi. Tahqiq: Husayn Salim Asad al-Darani (Riyadh: Dar al-Mughni li al-Nasyr wa al-Tauzi’ 2000)
Death Penalty Abolition (https: www.amnesty.my/abolish-death-penalty/ (11/12/2023)
Georges, Nael, The process of abolishing the death penalty in member states of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. Paris: ECPM (2020) (https://www.ecpm.org/app/uploads/2022/10/rapport-OCI-2020-GB-191120) retrieved 9/1/2023)
Ginat, Joseph, Blood disputed among bedouin and rural arabs in Israel: revenge, mediation, outcasting and family honour. (Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press,1987).
Hanafi, Mohd Shukri, ‘From jahiliyyah to islamic worldview: in a search of an Islamic educational philosophy’, Int.J of Humanities and Soc Sci . vol.3/3(2013): 213-221
Hardy, Michael J.L, Bloodfeuds and the payment of the blood money in the Middle East. (Leiden: Brill,1963).
Hasanain, Izzat, Jara'im al-i`tida' ala salamah al-ajsam baina al-shariah wa al-qanun. (Riyadh: Dar al-Ulum,1984).
Hassanein, Ahmed Samir, ‘The Impact of Islamic Criminal Law on the Qatari Penal Code’, Arab Law Quartely. 32(2018):60-79
Heidari, Mohammad Ali, `Study of Restorative Justice and Distributive Justice from the Perspective of Islamic Law and Jurisprudence’. New York Science Journal (2015): 80-85
Hood , Roger & Hoyle, Caroline, The Death Penalty: A Worldwide Perspective. (Oxford: Oxford University Press,2015).
Mohammad Hashim Kamali, 2000. Principles of Islamic Jurisprudence. (Cambridge: Islamic Texts Society,2000)
Ismail, Paizah, ‘Pelaksanaan Diyat dalam Kerangka Perundangan di Malaysia: Cabaran Fiqh Semasa’, Jurnal Fiqh, vol.9(2012):1-20.
Ismail, Shahrul Mizan, Zainal Abidin, Halila Faiza & Abdullah, Apnizan. 2017. Victim impact statement in criminal sentencing: success or setback for the criminal justice process?. Current Law Journal. 8:xv-xxxii
Ismail, Siti Zubaidah, ’The modern interpretation of the diyat formula for the quantum of damages: the case of homicide and personal injuries’, Arab Law Quarterly 26(2012): 361-379.
Ismail, Siti Zubaidah. (2017). Pampasan bagi kecederaan fizikal akibat kecuaian menurut perundangan Islam. Kuala Lumpur: ILBS.
Ismail, Siti Zubaidah. (2022). Debunking Myths About Diyat. IAIS Bulletin July-August 2022
Johnstone, Gerry. (2017). Restorative justice for victims: inherent limits. Restorative Justice, 5(3). 382-395
Kamali, Mohammad Hashim, Principles of Islamic Jurisprudence. (Cambridge: Islamic Texts Society,2000)
Khan, Ayaz. (2013). Human Ignorance (Jahiliyyah) Past & Present. The Dialogue, 2013. Vol. 8(4):346- 359.
Kovandic, Tomislaw V., Lynne M.Vieraitis, Denise Paquette Boots. (2009). Does the death penalty save lives? new evidence from state panel data. Criminology & Public Policy, vol.8(4): 803-843
Kramer, Matthew H. (2011). The ethics of capital punishment: a philosophical investigation of evil and its consequences. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Layish, Aharon. (2006). Interplay between tribal and shar`i law: a case of tibbawi blood money in the shari`a court of Kufra. Islamic Law and Society 13:1,63-75
Lewbel, Arthur, Calculating compensation in cases of wrongful death (2022). (https://www.fmwww.bc.edu /EC-P/wp523.pdf)11/12/2023
Lewis, Bernard, Ch. Pellat & J. Schacht. (1970). Encyclopedia of Islam. New Edition. London: Folios Limited.
Majah ibn, Muhammad ibn Yazid. (2000), Sunan Ibn Majah bi Sharh al-Imam Abi Hassan al-Hanafi . Beirut: Dar al-Ma`rifah.
Malaysiakini. ”Azalina: Bill to abolish mandatory death penalty to be tabled in Feb 2023” 21 Dec 2022. https://www.malaysiakini.com (retrieved 29/12/2023)
Mawla al- Bek, Muhammad Ahmad Jad, Ayyam al-'Arab fi al-Jahiliyyah. Cairo: Dar Ihya' al-Kutub al-`Arabiyyah, n.d).
Md Asri, M. H., & Ruslan, M. K, ‘The Crime of Hirabah: Approach, Justification and Significance’, Jurnal Syariah, 28/3)(2020): 383–416.
Meera, Ahmad Kameel Mydin, ‘Islamic gold dinar’, Subang Jaya: Pelanduk Publications,2002).
Mohamad, Abdul Hamid, Hukuman Pilihan Mengganti Hukuman Mati Mandatori: Pandangan Awal (2022) (www.tunabdulhamid.my)(retrieved 13/1/2024)
Mohamed, Ashgar Ali, ‘Should The Death Penalty Be Abolished?’ Malaysian Court Practice, (2018):6.
Mohammad Hashim Kamali, Crime and Punishment in Islamic Law: A Fresh Interpretation, (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019)
Mohd Dali, Nuradli Ridzwan Shah, The mechanism of gold dinar. Kuala Lumpur: AS Noordeen, 2004).
Mohd Noor, Azman & Ghazali, M. A., ‘Penyalahgunaan Dadah dan Kewajaran Peruntukan Hukuman Mati Ke atas Pengedar Dadah di Malaysia: Satu Analisis’, Jurnal Fiqh, 7(2010): 29-48.
Mohd Noor, Azman, ‘Mandatory Death Penalty: An Analysis According to the Practice of Law in Malaysia and Shariah". Journal of Law and Society 12(2008):13-27
Mokhtar, Nur Afizah Hanum, ‘Should death sentence be abolished?’, Malayan Law Journal, (2006): 3.
Nellis, Ashley, ‘Tinkering with life: a look at the inappropriateness of life without parole as an alternative to the death penalty’, U. Miami L.Rev. 67(2012):439-457
Neumayer, Eric, ‘Death penalty abolition and the ratification of the second optional protocol’, The International Journal of Human Rights. 12/1(2008a): 3-21
Neumayer, Eric, ‘Death penalty: the political foundation of the global trends awards abolition’, Human Rights Review. 9(2008b):241-268
Nicolson, R.A., A Literary History of the Arabs. (London: Curzon Press,2003).
Oliphant, Stephen N, ’Estimating the effect of death penalty moratoriums on homicide rates using the synthetic control method’, Criminology & Public Policy, vol.21/4(2022):915-944
Oswald, Andrew J., Powdthavee, Nattavudh, ’Death, happiness and the calculation of compensatory damages’, Journal of Legal Studies (2008):37.
Otto, Jan Michiel.(ed.), Sharia incorporated: a comparative overview of the legal systems of twelve muslim countries in past and present. Leiden: Leiden University Press,2010)
Pascoe, D., Last chance for life: clemency in Southeast Asian Death Penalty Case. Oxford: Oxford University Press,2019).
Qudamah, Abu Abdullah ibn Muhammad ibn, al-Mughni wa al-sharh al-kabir. Beirut: Dar al-Kitab al-Arabi,1983).
Sagoff, Syed Ahmad al-, Al-Diyah as compensation for homicide, wounding in Malaysia. (Kuala Lumpur: ILBS,2010).
Samuri, Mohd al-Adib, ’ Preventive theory as punishment justification: comparative analysis between civil and Islamic law’, Islamiyyat , 34(2012):131-143
San'ani al-, Subul al-Salam Sharh Bulugh al-Maram. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-Arabi,1987).
Scott, Austin W., ’The Pardoning Power’, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 284(2016):1, 95
Sharp, Susan F., Hidden Victims: The Effects of the Death Penalty on Families of the Accused. (New Jersey:Rutgers University Press,2005)
Shawkani al-, Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Muhammad, Nayl al-Awtar Sharh Muntaqa al-Akhbar. (Cairo: Dar al-Turath Library,nd).
Sijistani al-, Sunan Abi Daud. Tahqiq: Izzat Abid al-Da’as (Beirut: Dar Ibn Hazm 1997)
Snellenburg, Sidney C. (1987). Is there a reasonable alternative to death penalty. Judicature, 7 (1987): 5.
Stokes, Rachel, ‘A Fate Worse than Death? The Problem with Life Imprisonment as an Alternative to the Death Penalty’, in Jon Yorke (ed.), Against the Death Penalty: International Initiatives and Implications. (London: Routledge,2016).
Tirmizi al-, Al-Jami’ al-Kabir. Tahqiq: Basyar ‘Awad Ma;ruf (Beirut: Dar al-Gharb al-Islami 1996)
Tuna, Sedat, ‘The effect of politics in the jahiliyyah period on the literature’, OSUBIAD 12/2(2002) :1231 -1264.
Uddin, M., & Faruqi, S. S., ‘Power of Pardon in the Shariah and its Applicability in Common Law’, Jurnal Syariah, 32/2(2024), 246–274.
Utusan Malaysia, " konsep diyat sebagai ganti banduan hukuman mati sedia ada" accessed on 08 December 2022. https://www.utusan.com.my/berita/2022/06/konsep-diyat-sebagai-ganti-banduan-hukuman-mati-sedia-ada/
Vadillo, Umar, Fatwa on Paper Money. (Granada: Medina Press,1992).
van Zyl Smit, Dirk; Appleton, C; Vucong G. (eds). Life Imprisonment in Asia. Palgrave Advances in Criminology and Criminal Justice in Asia. (Palgrave Macmillan, Singapore,2023).
Weatherly, Robert & Helen Pittam, Helen. (2015). Money for life: the legal debate in China about criminal reconciliation in death penalty cases. Asian Perspective. 39:277-288
Wilson, Luke, ’Monetary compensation for injuries to the body, AD 602-1697’. in Jean Howard&Holly Dugan (eds.). Early modern cultural studies 1500-1700. (London: Palgrave Macmillan,2003):116-127
Wood, Arthur Lewis, ’The alternatives to the death penalty’, AAPSS. Vol.284, Issue 1(2016): 63
Yorke, Jon. (ed.), Against the Death Penalty: International Initiatives and Implications. (London: Routledge,2016).
Zaidan, Abdul Karim, Introduction to the Studies of Islamic Law. Beirut: Muassasah al-Risalah,2009).
Zuan, Chua Ming, ‘The appropriateness between the death penalty and murder offence under the Malaysian Penal Code’, Malayan Law Journal, (2010)5.
Zuhayli, Wahbah al-, Nazariyyah al-Daman aw Ahkam al-Mas'uliyyah al-Madaniyyah wa al-Jina'iyyah fi al-Fiqh al-Islami. (Damascus: Dar al-Fikr 1998)
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Jurnal Syariah
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
COPYRIGHT: All rights reserved. Not allowed to be reproduced any part of articles and contents of this journal in any form or by any way, whether electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without permission in writing from the Chief Editor, Jurnal Syariah.
